You don't stumble onto Fay by accident. That's rather the point. Milfay is a small unincorporated community in Creek County, Oklahoma, United States, about five and a half miles east of Stroud. As of the 2020 census, Milfay had a population of 74.
Dewey County holds 5 documented ghost towns, including Cestos, Lenora, Oakwood — Fay keeps them company on the map.
The story of Fay
Oklahoma's ghost towns got it from both sides — oil booms that built them overnight and the Dust Bowl that emptied them.
Milfay is a small unincorporated community in Creek County, Oklahoma, United States, about five and a half miles east of Stroud. As of the 2020 census, Milfay had a population of 74. The post office was established December 14, 1911. The community was named after Charles Mills and Edward Fay, two railroad officials.
What you'll find today
The on-the-ground condition of Fay is unverified — it's listed here with unknown status. That could mean standing buildings, or an empty field. Go prepared for either, and consider sharing what you find so the record improves.
Nobody has confirmed the access situation, so treat any visit as reconnaissance: verify land ownership first, and be ready to admire from the road.
Getting there
Here's the honest truth: access to Fay is unverified. We couldn't confirm whether the site sits on public land, private property, or something in between — so verify land ownership and local rules before visiting, and respect private property at all times. The mapped point for Fay is roughly 35.7517, -96.5592 — use it as a starting point and cross-reference a current topographic map before leaving pavement.
Good to know
Ghost-town etiquette is simple: take only photographs. Removing artifacts is illegal on public lands and disrespectful everywhere else — and on federal land it can be a serious offense.
Survey Map
Approximate position — verify access locally before visiting
Fay FAQs
01Where is Fay located?
02What county is Fay in?
03What is the history of Fay?
04What remains at Fay today?
05Can you visit Fay?
Sources: account based on Wikipedia (“Milfay, Oklahoma”), CC BY-SA.
More in Dewey County
Putnam
Dewey Co., Oklahoma
Read the guideOakwood
Dewey Co., Oklahoma
Read the guideLenora
Dewey Co., Oklahoma
Read the guideCestos
Dewey Co., Oklahoma
Read the guideDepew
Creek Co., Oklahoma
Read the guideShamrock
Creek Co., Oklahoma
Read the guide